Homepage

Homepage

Homepage

Homepage

Homepage

Homepage

Homepage

Homepage

Homepage

Homepage

Homepage

Homepage

Homepage


























I'm reading: The Man Who Broke My Heart, A Church Scandal and a Callous CousinTweet this!  Share on Facebook

The Man Who Broke My Heart, A Church Scandal and a Callous Cousin

by Judy Bachrach
JULY 8, 2009        TAGS: LOVE, RELIGION, ILLNESS, FAMILY         COMMENTS (1)
Dear Judy,

The only man I ever completely loved broke my heart. That was 10 years ago, when I was 22, overly jealous, overly possessive, marriage-hungry, and very dependent on him. He was 41 and well known in his field (film), so it was an unequal relationship. Also he lived, and still does, in L.A., and I had to commute to see him.

So I guess I blame myself for the end of the relationship as much as I blame him. He just wanted someone more independent than I was at the time. Anyway, that's what I finally figured out after three years of therapy.

About a year after he said goodbye, he married someone more self-confidant than I am (or was), had a couple of kids, and I went about my business, got an M.A. and started teaching.

I just learned he has colon cancer, and the cancer has spread. In other words, he's not expected to live more than two years.

My questions: Should I contact him now to tell him I forgive him for the pain he caused me? That I have some insights into the relationship as it was that I'd like to share? Maybe he feels guilty, and maybe I could ease some of that guilt.

Or is this a totally bad idea?

Corinna


Judy BachrachDear Corinna,

It's a totally bad idea.

In the first place, how do you know he feels guilty at all about the end of the relationship? And what do you need to forgive him for? Ending a bad relationship?

In the second, how do you know how his wife might feel about your conviction that a tete-a-tete with you is just what your ex-boyfriend needs, now that his life is ending?

And in the third, are you sure you're over this guy?

But let's forget about you and your pain for just a moment. The terminally ill need, as a general rule, to be around those they live with and love: spouses, children, current lovers, relatives with whom they are on good terms.

It is, in other words, not a great idea to spring surprise visits on the unsuspecting, especially when they are dying.

Thank you for writing,

Judy


--

Dear Judy,

I don't know if this is up your alley.  One of the people in my church died recently. He was wealthy and had the best doctors but prostate cancer got him anyway in the end. He was also married, with four children, and slept with a number of women, including the church secretary. She has a broken heart, still, because he left her.

I think maybe he got prostate cancer because he was an adulterer, although I realize there's no scientific proof of this.

Now some of the people in our church want to establish a scholarship in this man's name (a religious scholarship! for college students who want to go on and become pastors). So what do I do?

Do I inform our own pastor about this issue? In a way I don't want to because the two men were friends. But in a way I feel I should do what's right, no matter what. Also, I think the 11 members of our church who want to fund such a scholarship should be told so maybe the scholarship can be given another name. And maybe the man's widow, who is a very nice woman, but none too smart.

Your view?

Celia


Dear Celia,

I too feel you should do what's right, no matter what.

 Keep your mouth closed and your mind on spiritual matters.

Thank you for writing,

Judy


--

Dear Judy,

OK. My first cousin has had a hard life. Maybe a very hard life. Abusive father, who always belittled her (my uncle, naturally) and a nutty younger brother, whom she had to support for years until he died. Which broke her heart.

Our problem? (Here I'm talking about the rest of our entire family.) She feels sympathy for absolutely no one else. My mother, whom I adored, died recently. Cousin offered -- zero support. My husband has tongue cancer. Cousin offers -- zero support. I mean, barely a phone call, and certainly no offers of any help.

Instead, I have to hear things like: "Well, at least you have a loving husband, even if he can't talk any more." (She never married.) Or: "At least you still have a brother. I don't."

Most of the time I want to toss her out the window. What do you think?

Teddie


Dear Teddie,

I think you probably shouldn't toss your first cousin out the window.

No, no, I know you’re kidding.

Let's start with the obvious: Your cousin has issues, and it isn't just that her beloved brother died. Or that her father was verbally abusive. Or that she envies you your marital status.

She just isn't the sort of appealing and attractive person people are naturally drawn to, is she?

So let's acknowledge that and move on.

Now -- what do you expect out of your cousin that you honestly think she can give you?

Sound advice? Consolation? A shoulder to cry on? Tender love?

I bet it's none of the above.

Your cousin is -- your cousin. She won't change. You’re looking for solace in all the wrong places. Try a better relative or a good friend.

Thank you for writing,

Judy


 

A DRESS TO DIE FOR, A BRAGGART GRIEVES AND AN ANNIVERSARY PARTY
EUTHANASIA AND ITS DISCONTENTS, PART FOUR
SHOULD A FIVE YEAR-OLD SEE AN EMBALMED BODY? AND MORE...
HOW PATRICK SWAYZE STOLE MY HEART


PRINT    



COMMENTS (1)  

Latest News Delivered to Your Inbox - Sign up with our site and you will get the latest news about people and subjects that interest you.

 



Charlene Vickers
wrote on July 8, 2009 4:41am
Or maybe she's been hurt so much by her father that she simply doesn't care about any of her family any more, because she sees them as part of the problem. [Report Comment]

EXTREME DONATIONS, A SOMETIMES FRIEND AND BEQUEATHING A NECKLACE

PAINFUL CHARITIES, AN HONEST OBITUARY AND FINDING THE RIGHT WORDS

A PREMATURE FUNERAL, LAWYERING UP FOR INHERITANCE AND SYMPATHY FOR A NEIGHBOR

MAKING AMENDS, LIFE AFTER DEATH, AND ADVOCATING CREMATION

SCATTERING ADVICE, TREADING LIGHTLY AND FUNERAL INVITES

STEP DAUGHTER TROUBLES, CHILDREN AT A FUNERAL AND FOOTING THE BILL

AVOIDING CONFRONTATION, AN EXPECTED INHERITANCE, AND RUDE REMARKS AT A FUNERAL

INAPPROPRIATE REMARKS, UNWELCOME COMMISERATION AND ANGLING FOR A JOB

CHOOSING AN ADVOCATE, HONEST ANSWERS AND MARRYING FOR MONEY

BANKING SPERM, ARGUMENTS FOR HOSPICE AND JUNK FOOD AT THE END

ARRANGING VISITS, MY WAY AND A LOVELY WIDOW

THE NECKLACE, WITHHELD SYMPATHY AND FATALISTIC FLORIDIANS

FINDING HOSPICE, A BEREAVED NEIGHBOR AND A SECRET AFFAIR

ABANDONING THE DEPRESSED, A TOE JAM AND NEIGHBORLY CARE

FOUL PLAY, SNAPPY COMEBACKS AND 10 THINGS NEVER TO SAY TO THE DYING

A CAT'S LAST TRIP, A NEIGHBOR'S ACCIDENT AND POORLY TIMED NUPTIALS

UNWELCOME GALLOWS HUMOR, A SECRET DAUGHTER AND BURIAL SLIGHTS

A HOUSE APART, GIVING BAD NEWS AND WAITING ON A WILL

INCENDIARY REMARKS, UNDUE OPTIMISM AND AVOIDING BAD JOKES

GRAVE SUSPICIONS, ADULT DECISIONS AND PREPOSTEROUS PLANS

SYMPATHY CARD WITH MONEY, BUYING A MOTORCYCLE AND A STONE-COLD PARTNER

MARRYING A STEP-DAUGHTER, ACCUSING A NURSING HOME AND A PARTNER'S LAMENT

AN OBJECTIONABLE ADOPTION, AIR-TIGHT SOLUTIONS AND TELLING YOUR KIDS

PRETENDING TO MOURN, A PLAIN WOODEN BOX AND A TWIN'S RETORT

A FORMER FRIEND, NOT SAD AND FUR DISINHERITANCE

MEMORIAL FOR AN ESTRANGED SISTER, SUPPORT GROUP TROUBLES AND BIN LADEN BURIAL

COMPASSIONATE PARTNERS, ENVIRONMENTAL HAZARDS AND AVOIDING HELL

BURY ME WITH MY DOG, BOOK CLUB MEMORIALS AND ENSURING INHERITANCE

A HERMES SCARF, DISCUSSING THE AFTERLIFE AND AN EX-LOVER'S WIFE

DISINHERITANCE TROUBLES, SEEING THE WORLD AND A HYPOCHONDRIAC BROTHER

A SECRET HUSBAND, WOOLEN COFFINS AND AN EXCLUSIVE GOODBYE

WORDS AT A FUNERAL, LAVISH BURIALS AND THE AFTERLIFE

ICE COLD JOKES, DEATHBED VISITS AND NATURAL BURIAL

VISITING MOTHER, TWIN SISTER BENEFICIARY AND SECOND OPINIONS

GOING HOME, A REVERSE MORTGAGE AND A LONGTIME GIRLFRIEND

SETTING THINGS STRAIGHT, SAYING NO AND BRINGING UP A BROOCH

A ROTTEN GRANDCHILD, WHEN PUSH COMES TO SHOVE AND AN ANGRY SON

DIABETES DIATRIBES, TELLING YOUR KIDS AND FEARING A WILL

DUCKING PHONE CALLS, GOOD LUCK GOES BAD AND A BOYFRIEND'S OVERDOSE

A DEAD LOVER, A SMUTTY INHERITANCE AND A FAIR SPLIT

CREMATION COST, A RAINY DAY FUND AND A MOOCHING BROTHER

SEEING A MOVIE, PLANNING A FUNERAL AND A STUBBORN FIANCE

CARING FOR AN ABUSIVE FATHER, INHERITENCE PROBLEMS AND AN UNPLEASANT COLLEAGUE

TAKING CARE OF PEPPER, WILL DILLY DALLYING AND SEEING A SISTER

THE HALO EFFECT, A NEW WIFE AND THE WIDOW JOSEPHINE

MY NEW AGE COUSIN, A CHATTY TRAINER AND DONATING LIFE

FEELING OPPRESSED, MY SO-CALLED FRIENDS AND A HATED FATHER

STEPPING OUT, SAYING GOODBYE TO MOM AND SIGNS OF ALZHEIMER'S

SYMPATHY FROM AFAR, NEEDY NEIGHBORS AND FINDING GOD

THE IMPORTANCE OF LIES, FINDING HOSPICE AND DEATH JAGS

WHAT COMES AFTERWARDS: WILLS AND HOUSES

STAYING AT HOME, A GOOD DEATH AND EXCESSIVE DONATIONS

MY HUSBAND'S GIRLFRIEND, A SHOUTING BOSS AND READY-FOR-THE-GRAVE

ASKING THE QUESTION, CHANGING CARE AND PERFECT SILENCE

MASS EMAILS, NO SYMPATHY CARDS AND DEATHBED APOLOGIES

INCURABLE SECRETS, AN UGLY COUSIN AND A SMELLY EX

ENSURING YOUR ESTATE FALLS IN THE RIGHT HANDS

BAD MOUTHING THE DEAD, EMBALMING AND GUILT

THE RAGE OF THE DYING, FUNERAL GLOATING AND ALZHEIMER'S DESTRUCTION

BURIAL AT SEA, PHANTOM SYMPTOMS AND A DISTANT FATHER

FEELING LIKE A BRAT, ENSURING INHERITANCE AND FUNERAL TRUSTS

SHOULD A FIVE YEAR-OLD SEE AN EMBALMED BODY? AND MORE...

A TRAVELING BODY, FEASTING AT A FUNERAL AND BUSTING EUPHEMISMS

WHEN NOTHING CAN BE RECONCILED

PANNA COTTA, STAYING OUT OF THE ICU AND AVOIDING A SKUNK

THE SIMPLE THINGS, AN ESTRANGED MOTHER AND A BOSSY BROTHER

OFFENSIVE CHILDREN, EXPENSIVE COFFINS AND RUDE WAKE GUESTS

CRUELTY, FEAR AND ANGER AT THE END

CORPSE REAL ESTATE, SECRET FAMILIES AND DIVIDING A BEQUEST

LYING TO THE DYING, PRE-PLANNING AND AN UNLOVED COUSIN

THE OTHER FAMILY, APATHY AND CYBER SNOOPING

SURVIVORS, COST OVERRUNS AND REINCARNATION

AN AWFUL PATIENT, RESTORING BEAUTY AND THANK YOU NOTES

A STEPFATHER'S NEGLECT, A CHRISTIAN BURIAL AND A DYING TWIN

A DISTANT BOYFRIEND, PRE-NEED QUESTIONS AND HUSBAND IN A COMA

A MISTRESS CALLS, A FRIEND'S MOTHER AND BEING THERE

THE LIMITS OF CARE, SUMMER CHOICES AND CHURCH GIVING

WHEN TO STAY AT HOME, WHEN TO VISIT

AN OLDER FIANCE, TO SUE OR NOT TO SUE AND DISAPPEARING MALICE

MYTHIC PLANS, OFFICE COLLECTIONS AND BEING POLITE

CHILDHOOD GRIEF, A TWIN'S DEATH AND A STEP-DAUGHTER GRIPES

CELEBRATING LIFE AND NEARING THE END

AN OLD SCHOOL MAMA, A CHEATING HUSBAND AND A MOUTHY NEIGHBOR

SOCIAL REJECTION, A CHATTY DOORMAN AND POLITICAL DISPUTES

FINDING SUPPORT, A JEALOUS WIFE AND A BORING WAKE

AN AILING MOTHER OVERSEAS AND A SCHEMING BROTHER

AN ACCIDENTAL SUICIDE, A NEW WIFE AND THE LONG HAUL

A BIOLOGICAL FATHER, HEAVEN, HELL AND UNSOCIABLE STEPMOTHER

POWER OF ATTORNEY, A LIVING WILL AND A BAD-MOUTHING MOTHER

EXTREME DRIVING, TALKING TO A DEAD HUSBAND AND FEARING A SON

A LOYAL/MALICIOUS AUNT, VISITING A VICIOUS SISTER AND A LOVER'S FUNERAL

A FATHER IN JAIL, A CLASSMATE'S FUNERAL AND A PASTOR'S LAMENT

HIDDEN RAGE, A DISAPPEARING HUSBAND AND A CONDO IN PHOENIX

THE MISDIAGNOSIS, QUITTING SMOKING AND SMOKING AT THE END

MY DAD'S LAST NAME, A RUSSIAN LAST NAME AND A ROTTEN FRIEND

A WEEPY CLASSMATE, FROM BEDSIDE TO HONG KONG AND A VICIOUS MOTHER

HOW DO I TELL MY TEENAGE DAUGHTER THAT HER FATHER IS DYING OF CANCER?

A SMOKER, A PAIR OF EARRINGS AND THE AFTERLIFE

WHAT DOES DEATH LOOK LIKE, A SURVIVOR'S BOASTS AND VISITING A DYING BROTHER

HEAVY GYM TALK, DRUGS THAT HASTEN DEATH AND A MISTRESS REVEALED

A DEAD PRINCIPAL, A HOSPICE NURSE AT BOOK CLUB AND A GOOD FRIEND

A DISRESPECTED ONCOLOGIST, A GRIEVING HOUSEKEEPER AND IMPROPER CONDOLENCES

AN ESTRANGED UNCLE, A SCHIZOPHRENIC MOM AND PROBLEMS WITH A JUG

THE HALO EFFECT AND FORGETTING A DEATH

A DRESS TO DIE FOR, A BRAGGART GRIEVES AND AN ANNIVERSARY PARTY

NO THANK YOU NOTE, HIRING PEOPLE WITH CANCER AND HONORING A STEPFATHER

A FIRST CLASS BODY, THE DEATH RATTLE AND HELPING A FAMILY FRIEND

A NEEDY SISTER, FURIOUS STEP-CHILDREN AND WHY WE TALK ABOUT DEATH

A STEPMOTHER'S ODD REQUESTS, PAYING BACK A LOAN AND HALLUCINATIONS AT THE END

PRETENDING HIS WIFE IS DEAD, A LAST WILL AND WHAT TO SAY

DYING IN THE SADDLE, CREMATION PROBLEMS AND A MOTHER'S MENTAL ILLNESS

MY LATE BOYFRIEND'S PARENTS, PROBLEMS WITH A WILL AND HOW TO LISTEN

THOUSANDS OF MILES FROM A LOVED ONE, AN ABSENT COUSIN AND MAKING PLANS

REFUSING TO MAKE END-OF-LIFE-DECISIONS AND PLANNING A SENSIBLE FUNERAL

GRIEVING FOR A POODLE, SHOPPING FOR HOSPICE AND HAVING TROUBLE WITH A SPIRITUAL COUNSELOR

A CHILD MOLESTER, A DYING FRIEND AND MISSTEPS IN FRONT OF A WIDOW

A POLITICIAN'S DEMISE, A WIDOW'S FINANCES AND ADVICE FOR A SIMPLE FUNERAL

THE METAPHYSICS OF ASH SCATTERING, A LIVING WILL AND A SILENT FRIEND

A DEADBEAT BROTHER, SPURNED IN-LAWS, AND THE ANNOYANCE OF CONSTANT COMPANY

A TYRANNICAL WIDOWER, EMAIL DEATH NOTIFICATION AND AN ILLEGITIMATE CHILD RETURNS

DO I HAVE TO PAY FOR MY PARENTS' FUNERALS?

OFFICE GIFT GIVING GOES AWRY, OVERSEAS EXPENSES AND A CAR CRASH

TOO MANY VISITORS, ADVICE FOR A HOSPICE WORKER AND A CHILD'S ROOM

A HAPPY WIDOW, QUICK DEATHS AND A LINGERING VOICEMAIL MESSAGE

A SON'S PARTNER IN THE FAMILY VAULT, REPRESSED MEMORIES OF ABUSE AND HELL

THE PLEASURES OF CHEESECAKE, A VACATION FROM DEATH AND DYING AT HOME

A NANNY'S LAMENT, A PEDESTRIAN'S DEATH AND A MOTORCYCLE

GIVING UP, THE NEEDY WIDOW AND A FORGOTTEN LEGACY

MY CRAZY SISTER, A WHACKO CHARITY AND WHETHER TO BRING A CHILD TO A FUNERAL

A MURDERED MOM, QUICK WILLS AND RECOVERING FROM HOSPICE

A FRIEND SUFFERS ALONE, CREMATION AND JUDAISM, AND A LONELY CARETAKER

JUDGING LUNG CANCER, GLOATING AT A FUNERAL AND BUYING AN URN

A SECOND OPINION, THE OVERSHARING WIDOWER AND A GUILTY MOTHER

DEBUNKING FUNERAL MYTHS, FALLING IN LOVE WITH YOUR EX, AND A BOOZER FIANCE

ENDING YOUR LIFE, LATE CONDOLENCES, AND CALLOUS CO-WORKERS

A FATHER'S NEW GIRLFRIEND, A DEMANDING WIFE AND REFUSING CANCER TREATMENT

LIVING WILL TROUBLE, A HUSBAND DIES IN JAIL AND A NEW WAY TO BEQUEATH

IN LOVE WITH A WIDOWER, TERMINAL DEPRESSION AND BUCKING DEPENDENCY

GUILT FOR PAST DEEDS, A SICK TEACHER AND RECOVERING A PAIR OF EARRINGS

DEALING WITH DENIAL, A MOTHER'S MALICE AND A WAYWARD WIDOWER

HIDING THE D-WORD, WHEN TO TELL THE KIDS AND HOW TO AVOID SPEAKING AT A FUNERAL

FORMER LOVERS, PRAYERS LEFT UNSAID AND MOVING TO NEW HOUSE

AT A LOSS FOR WORDS, SIBLING DISCORD AND HAVING A BABY

A MANGY DOG, THE DEATH OF A LITTLE SISTER AND DONATING A MOTHER'S STUFF

A PUSHY PRIEST, SUSPICIOUS DENTAL WORK AND GETTING A FRIEND'S GROOVE BACK

AN ENEMY AT WORK FALLS ILL, THE BIG NOTHING AND DENYING THE INEVITABLE

A MISTRESS'S GRIEF, DEMENTIA'S TOLL AND GOSSIP AT THE DEATHBED

DIFFERING VALUES, PRIVATE GOODBYES AND RECURRENT MEMORIES OF 9/11

TROUBLE WITH AN OUT-OF-TOWN RELATIVE, INVASIVE QUESTIONS AND EXPENSIVE SUPPORT

STEP-FATHERS, ABUSIVE EX'S AND DO NOT RESUSCITATE ORDERS

MOTHERS-IN-LAW, UNEXPECTED CHANGES AND HEALTH ANXIETY

DESERVED AFFECTION, THE FAMILY ACCOUNTANT AND ICE CREAM

OUT-OF-TOWN BURIAL, CONDOLENCE NOTES AND EARLY ONSET ALZHEIMER'S

HOW LONG TO STAY, A USED CAR AND A DYING EX-HUSBAND

PAYING THE MORTGAGE AND GRAND THEFT JEWELRY

SYMPATHY CARDS, ASSISTING SUICIDE AND INAPPROPRIATE FUNERAL WEAR

ENERGY, GRIEVING AND MEMORY, JUDY'S THIRD COLUMN

EATING, ANGER AND ATHEISTS, ASK JUDY'S SECOND COLUMN

BIRTHDAYS, GUILT AND SUICIDE, ASK JUDY'S FIRST COLUMN

VIEW ALL BLOG POSTS



A FULL MEASURE OF DEVOTION
DYING FOR SCIENCE
"WE ARE ALL HOKIES"
THE LIFE AND DEATH OF THE DEATH OF GOD




CREATIVE NONFICTION